Thursday, 16 October 2014

Case Study 2: Feminism, sexism, and challenging the conventional Marvel comic: Alias, The Secret Origin of Jessica Jones,




- Printed under Marvel’s Max imprint, meaning it is not for children!


 



















Jessica Jones is shown as an average school girl (and drawn as such) who has a crush on Peter Parker, who is too busy with a crush on the prettier Liz Allen to notice her. The art is used well here, intentionally resembling the work of Steve Ditko, the artist who first drew Spider-man, as it is purposefully a flash back to this exact time period and scene. She is then scene masturbating to a picture of the human Torch, of the Fantastic Four, when her brother walks in to her embarrassment. (Making her seemingly more relatable and real). The next day in the car on a trip to Disneyworld, her brother teases her for this, causing an argument between the siblings in the back seat distracting their dads driving causing him to crash into ‘experimental material,’ probably radioactive, an almost mickey take of the overused-way Marvel give their heroes powers, but none the less fits into this world. This kills her family and send her into a coma. Upon awakening Jessica returns to her normal life being bullied at school. After running home upset that Peter only now talks to her, in pity, she realises she is in the air, flying. She falls into the ocean when Thor saves her. (Note here the importance of Thor being male). He then says “young maiden of Midgard, thy language leaves something to be desired” after she curses trying to catch her breath. Thor saves her, but still insults her before leaving abruptly. 
 


We come to the present (where the art is more realistic and gritty in the sense of anatomy, colour and clothing), when Jessica gets a phone call from ‘The Purple Man’s (Killgrave)” victim’s families asking her for a favour, she looks horrified and throws up. She goes to meet the families and they ask her to make Killgrave admit to all the murders he committed by taking over people’s minds, and not just the ones he was found guilty of. She agrees due to the families hopeful stares. She wakes up to find she was at Luke Cage’s house, drunk, threw up all over herself and made a fool of herself at his house, hurting is feelings in a drunken rant. She goes on to tell her why exactly she quit being a superhero.





















Jessica tells of when she was the superhero Jewel, (the art now in the classic style of Marvel comics), when she attempted to sort out a fight he caused he grasps her in his mind control, ordering her to remove her clothes. She is about to, before he then orders her to ‘take care of the police that are arriving”, as he wants to enjoy his meal. Unable to do otherwise, without freewill, she does so.  He keeps her for eight months, where though he never raped her, he tortured her mentally through humiliation. He would (in the words of Jessica) “he made me fucking stand there and watch him fuck other girls. Telling me to wish it was me. Telling me to cry while I watched...He would make me beg him for it. He would just sit there and at his request I would beg him for it, I would beg him to fuck me, I would beg him ‘till I cried...Eight months. I lay at his feet. I slept on his floor. I bathed him.” The evil villain told he did this in revenge for when other heroes had defeated him in the past, this was his revenge on the superhero.  Her family and friends didn’t even realise she was gone for this time. 

 



















Back to the superhero and colourful illustrations show The Purple man telling Jessica to “put on her stupid fucking slut costume” and kill the Avengers, or “ any costume fuck” who gets in her way.
She unwillingly and uncontrollably heads to the Avengers Mansion, and after knocking out the Scarlet Witch, is attacked by the Avengers.  The Scarlet Witches’ partner Vision punches her in the face, just before Warbird (note a female Superhero) saves her and carries her away before the Avengers can do any more damage. Jessica says her “neck was messed up. My nose was broken. Lost some teeth. I did some damage to my spine, and my retina detached.” Sending her into a coma shes says doctors said  it was brought on more by the mental trauma than physical. “The Purple man mind fuck. The Avengers assbeating. The physical stress of the whole thing.” 





















This shows that when all the male Avengers went to attack Jessica, with an angry violent husband punching her, it was only the female member Warbird who saved her from them, who did the right thing. It also doesn’t shy away from violence. Average comics (especially Marvel) show violence so regularly without consequence it becomes the norm. Here, one punch from a superhuman had devastating effects. Even earlier in the comic Thor simply pulled her out the water, not really comforting her or staying long to see if she was alright, showing a somewhat cold and half-arsed view of the male superhero. On the subject on gender, in is psychic hero Jean Grey (could have been male hero Charles Xaiver, who has the same power) but it is female hero Jean Grey who helps Jessica out of the coma. When she awakes, Jean tells her she has gotten rid of all traces of The Purple Man’s mind control, and that Daredevil has got The Purple man behind bars.  
She then turns up to the Avengers mansion, to apologize for her actions when Scarlet Witch (female heroine) says sympathetically, “well you were hardly to be blamed for that,” while the male heroes involved in the confutation remain quite, their body language looking uncomfortable at her presence. Perhaps unable to admit their wrong doing in a violent attack against the innocent Jessica. Nick Fury, offers her a job at S.H.I.E.L.D, saying “You’re perfect for it, what you went through..and you came out the other side in one piece?.. You’re a survivor, and a fighter, and we need you on our team.” These words could  echo to an audience who have been through difficult times of mental and or physical stress to give them compliment, and applaud their strength, and even find Jessica more relatable than she already is; a girl who was over looked in high school, fantasying about good looking members of the opposite sex, arguing with her little brother, sexually oppressed and humiliated by men, drinks to cope with bad memories. She is also often lacked sympathy from her ‘heroes’ and question whether their always doing the right thing, something many people find when looking up at their childhood heroes; everyone’s human.  .She is not only relatable for women, but also men could find alot of these qualities relatable. 





















She refuses Fury’s offer, asking if it’s a ‘pay off’ and doubting his saying of she has what it takes, saying “did you see what happened to me, that is the result of having the opposite of what it takes.” showing insecurity, self blame and even more relatable qualities people feel when their down. She quits the superhero gig, and hangs up her costume. 


 We come back to present day, where she just finishes explaining this to Luka Cage, her former lover. He says he will take care of this Purple man thing, what the victims families have asked her to do (being the caring and protective man that he is.) She says she has to do it, and he respects that; “good for you.”
In a creepy confrontation with the Purple man (in jail) the Purple man seems well aware he is in a comic book, constantly breaking the fourth wall. “Well if it isn’t my favourite comic book character of all time.” He even goes on to describe the panels as they are layed out. “Interior shot. Jail. Day. Jessica Jones...the ex-costumed super-hero, now private eye, comes face-to-face with her greatest foe, her worst nightmare...the Killgrave, the Purple Man. Tight shot on Jessica. She stares blankly, Trying not to give Killgrave the satisfaction of how much this confrontation is getting to her, But her eyes are glassy with held back tears. Her quivering lip betrays her.” All of this is identical to the comic page layout, apart from the expression of Jessica’s face. She doesn’t look scared or intimidated by the Purple Man anymore. In a uncomfortable few sentences the Purple man says “I wouldn’t flip to the back of the book, something really bad is going to happen to you Jessica. I wouldn’t turn to the end. Something really terrible happens.” She doesn’t get the confession she came for. 

 



















Upon returning home she finds out that there has been a break out of a maximum security prison and the Purple Man has escaped. Soon the Purple man has the street in a ful scale riot after he demands everyone to kill each other.  Jessica is present, and though the Avengers are there, it is a psychic projection of Jean Grey that tells Jessica there is a psychic trigger in her mind that can make her immune to the Purple Man’s orders, all she has to do is choose to switch it on. She dose, and when thePurple man demands she break Captain America’s back “Do it now whore!” She punches the Purple Man in the face, and beats him senseless, to which the Avengers compliment her, “Oh my god, Oh my Jessica! You did it! Look at you” as she cries over Warbird’s shoulder, seemingly thinking that these violent actions shouldn’t be so well congratulated, and maybe the ‘World’s Mightiest Heroes” are a bit too comfortable with these horrific acts of violence, or perhaps she cries because revenge didn’t give her the satisfaction she had hoped for, and it didn’t make the pain go away. Perhaps both? 

The story concludes with Jessica telling Luke she is pregnant (something that has been hinted at, and that Luke is the father, but not before he has already told her he’s developed emotional feelings for her. Luke appears happy at the news, asks her is she wants to keep it to which she says “Very, very, very much.” He responds “alright then, New Chapter.” This scene is drawn and uses colour, location, dialogue and expression including body language to make the scene the right amount of awkward, touching, and relatable to anyone who’s had to tell someone how they feel about them, and putting those fragile yet strong emotions free to their knowledge hoping for the same in response, and how tense and happy that atmosphere can feel, like butterflies in the stomach. 


 This comic is incredible. The art is reminiscent of the time period of comics that is meant to be set in, making the character of Jessica feel like she has always existed in the Marvel universe and she has simply always been overlooked, just as she is throughout the comic by all except Luke Cage, Jean Grey and Warbird. The art during her superhero days looks more sexist in terms of body structure and anatomy of Jessica, perhaps a dig at the sexist view of women in popular superhero comics, or the view in which The Purple Man see’s her. Though I would argue The Purple Man doesn’t see Jessica as a object of sexual desire, despite him calling her “Pretty,” but more of a object he wants to hurt as she labels herself a superhero, and it is his hate for crime fighters that makes him want to subdue, mentally and physically torture, and belittle her, (hence constantly calling her a “slut” or “whore” and making her his slave, but never have sex with her, despite making her beg for it.) I think this shows The Purple Man hates Jessica, not for who she is, but what she stands for as a superhero, and because of his past defeats by crime fighters wants to make himself feel better by making one admire him in every way. 

It confronts the violence so passively used in comics, by showing its devastating effects. It also shows is a rare comic that shows a female lead who is character full, relatable, not sexist in any way and defeats the oppressing male villain. Karen Healey writes in her essay titled The Secret Origins of Jessica Jones: Multiplicity, Irony and a Feminist Perspective on Brian Michael Bendis’s Alias that:
“Jessica’s final triumph over Killgrave is enabled by Jean [Grey]’s act of sisterhood and activated through her own agency. Moreover, Killgrave’s prophecy that “something really bad will happen to you” is denied. Jessica’s secret origin insertion into continuity is not punished, but redeemed by her win. Jessica’s victory, then is not only satisfying in the comic book terms of good triumphing over evil, but a symbolically feminist blow against the controlling, all-knowing patriarchy in suitably superheroic terms.”


 I agree with Healey on this point, though I would like to have seen Jessica to pick up her Superhero mantle once again, and not let it be ruined by The Purple Man’s villainy, because then, ultimately, he won. He got rid of one more superhero in the world. Yes Jessica is still a private eye and helps people, and arguably this end shows that the male’s view and representation of women in the mainstream media can seriously damage women’s confidence and create perverse demented men who expect women to do whatever they say. Perhaps the villain of The Purple Man is meant to be a metaphor. But I would have loved to see Jessica Jones be strong enough to overcome his evil and re-take up the mantle of Jewel. Though it is a very arguable (and a good, valid point) that it was not The Purple Man that made her quit, but more the overly violent, “attack first as questions later” actions of her would be co-workers The Avengers that lost her faith in Superheroes. Roz Kaveny writes in Superheroes! Capes and crusaders in comics and film “The Superhero world failed to save her, and then it nearly killed her....healing takes time and not conveniently at the end of a three dollar issue.” 


I had heard of Jessica Jones before, but never really looked into her story as I wasn’t as interested in detective stories as much as superhero ones, (which is partly why I’d like to see Jessica’s return as Jewel.) I understand that these two genre’s of detective stories and superhero ones cross over alot, (in such characters as Rorschach and even Batman being labelled The world’s greatest detective! starting out in detective comics. But would audience’s read Batman’s comic’s if never put the cowl on and solved cases and Bruce Wayne? Was it not the moral ambiguity and wearing of the cowl that made him different and exciting?) But perhaps superheroes are so over-done that Jessica’s story is reverting to the old ways of no masks, as it’s more original these days. But maybe it’s my narrow-mindedness that I’d rather have a costumed super powered crime fighter in stories and not the fault of this extremely well thought about, relatable, strong character in Jessica Jones.

Kaveny states that “Jessica’s arc has to do with her accepting she is a flawed human being, whether she identifies as a superhero or not, which is to say that she moves towards the complexity of life in Marvel, and away from the shiny idealism of her earlier shinier model of being a superhero (Jewel) which was partly a critique of Marvel’s early days, and even more of a critique of their major rival DC.” Understanding Kaveny’s point, I would still like to see to see Jewel back in action, dealing with these conflicted emotions, disliking the Avengers and mainstreams heroes, constantly uncertain of if what she does (and superhero-ing in general) is right, and attempting to deal with super-villians in a more defensive than aggressive manor, and seeing where that could lead our heroine. Dose this give her conflict with heroes when they fight villains, making her not on either side but better than both? Is she strong enough not to loose her temper when fighting villains that have harmed those close to her (like The Vision did when she attacked his wife the Scarlet Witch?) This would be interesting to see such a powerful hero with a wider gaze of right and wrong, and unsure guideline to follow, leading her to sometimes going toe to toe with the heroes. Part of the appeal of superhero comics is the colourful costumes and extraordinary powers, people doing incredible things and I personally feel she should become this new kind of hero who can embody these things and dislike superheroes despite being one. It would be something audiences haven’t scene and give her this self loathing but complicated relationship with herself, a duty to do what is right but hating herself for doing it. But perhaps this would make her less relatable, and the thing most people would really do is walk away from that style of life if all it does is let you down and disappoint you.

After such an engaging, original (apart from her typical power of strength, invulnerability and flight) character that has such a thought provoking and well written origin story and terrifying and unlikeable arch-villian, I would love to see Jessica Jones, and even Jewel, have a future series in the Marvel Universe, and with a Television show confirmed, that looks extremely possible. 



 Michael Bendis, B. (2008) Alias: Volume 4: The Secret Origin of Jessica Jones. New York: Marvel Comics, 2004.

Roz Kaveny (2008) Superheroes! Capes and Crusaders in Comics and Film I.B Tauris & Co Ltd. Great Britian
Michael Bendis, B. (2008) Alias: Volume 4: The Secret Origin of Jessica Jones. New York: Marvel Comics, 2004.
Healy, K. (2006) Available at: http://girl-wonder.org/papers/healey.html (Accessed on: 16/10/2014)

No comments:

Post a Comment